Cabernet Franc vs Merlot
Bordeaux's Right Bank partners — one aromatic and savoury, the other plush and rounded.
Cabernet Franc and Merlot are the two grapes behind the great wines of Bordeaux's Right Bank — Saint-Émilion and Pomerol — where they are almost always blended together. On their own they make very different wines: Cabernet Franc is lighter, more aromatic, and savoury, while Merlot is rounder, softer, and fruitier. Because they are so often poured under a single Bordeaux label, many drinkers have tasted both without ever telling them apart. Learning the difference sharpens how you read a wine list and helps you pick the right red for the food and the moment.
At a Glance
Cabernet Franc
Merlot
The clearest difference is aromatic character. Cabernet Franc is a perfumed, savoury grape — its signature is a mix of red fruit (raspberry, red plum), floral violet, and a distinctive leafy, herbal edge that can read as bell pepper, tomato leaf, or graphite pencil shavings. That greenness comes from pyrazine compounds, and it is more pronounced in cooler climates or in cooler vintages. At its best, in the Loire Valley or on the limestone of Saint-Émilion, Cabernet Franc smells of crushed raspberries and violets with a savoury, almost tobacco-like undertone. It is a wine of scent and lift rather than sheer weight.
Merlot is the rounder, fleshier of the two. Its thin skins and early ripening give softer tannins and a plummy, black-cherry fruitiness that is immediately appealing. Where Cabernet Franc has an aromatic, savoury edge, Merlot leans towards ripe fruit, chocolate, and — when oaked — vanilla and mocha. It fills the mid-palate with a generous, velvety texture, which is exactly why it is so often used to add flesh and approachability to a blend. Merlot is the grape that makes a young Bordeaux drinkable while the more structured components soften.
Structurally, the two sit close together but not identically. Both are lighter and softer than Cabernet Sauvignon, but Cabernet Franc usually carries slightly higher acidity and a firmer, more sinewy tannin, which gives its wines a sense of freshness and cut. Merlot is plusher and lower in acid, which is what makes it feel smoother and more immediately generous. In a glass side by side, Cabernet Franc feels taut and lifted; Merlot feels round and mellow.
Climate shapes both grapes strongly. In cool regions — the Loire, cooler Bordeaux vintages — Cabernet Franc shows its herbal, red-fruited, high-acid side and Merlot stays fresh and medium-bodied. In warmer regions — Tuscany, Washington State, Chile — both ripen further: Cabernet Franc loses much of its greenness and gains darker fruit, while Merlot becomes richer, more full-bodied, and chocolatey. This is why a Chinon Cabernet Franc and a warm-climate New World Merlot can seem worlds apart even though the grapes are close cousins in Bordeaux.
It is worth remembering that these two are genuinely related: Cabernet Franc is one of the parent grapes of both Merlot and Cabernet Sauvignon. That shared lineage is part of why they blend so seamlessly on the Right Bank, where Merlot provides the plush fruit core and Cabernet Franc adds perfume, structure, and freshness on top.
Which Is Better for Beginners?
For a newcomer to red wine, Merlot is the gentler starting point. Its soft tannins, low acidity, and ripe plum-and-cherry fruit make it easy to enjoy on its own, without food or bottle age to smooth it out. A supermarket Merlot from Chile or Washington State is about as friendly as red wine gets — round, fruity, and undemanding.
Cabernet Franc asks a little more curiosity of a beginner, but it is not difficult so much as different. Its herbal, leafy aromatics — that hint of bell pepper or pencil — can be surprising the first time, and its brighter acidity and firmer tannin give it more grip than Merlot. That said, a ripe, fruit-forward Cabernet Franc from a warm vintage or a New World producer is very approachable, and many people fall for its perfume quickly once they know what to expect.
A good route in is to start with an everyday Merlot to get comfortable with soft red fruit, then try a Loire Cabernet Franc such as a Chinon or Saumur-Champigny to meet its aromatic, savoury style. From there, a Right Bank Bordeaux — a Saint-Émilion — shows how beautifully the two grapes work together in a single glass.
The honest rule: choose Merlot first if you want easy, fruity, and smooth, and reach for Cabernet Franc when you are ready for something more aromatic and savoury. Neither is harder to like — they simply appeal in different ways.
Cabernet Franc or Merlot With Food?
Cabernet Franc is one of the most food-friendly red grapes there is, precisely because of its freshness and savoury, herbal character. Its brighter acidity cuts through fat and lifts a plate, and its leafy, red-fruited profile flatters herbs and green vegetables that can trip up bigger reds. It is a classic match for roast pork, herb-crusted lamb, charcuterie, and — thanks to that tomato-leaf note — it is one of the best reds for tomato-based dishes, from a ragù to a simple pizza. It also handles grilled vegetables and mushroom dishes with ease.
Merlot is the more crowd-pleasing partner for richer, simpler fare. Its plush fruit and soft tannin make it comfortable alongside roast chicken, duck, mushroom risotto, pasta with a tomato or meat sauce, and milder cheeses. It rarely overpowers a plate, which makes it a safe choice when the meal is varied or the table is mixed. A riper, oaked Merlot has enough weight to sit beside grilled red meat too, though it stops short of Cabernet Sauvignon's structure.
Both grapes love the same broad territory — roast meats, earthy flavours, tomato and mushroom — which is why they blend so well and why either works for a mid-week roast. Serve both slightly cool, around 16 to 18°C; a few minutes in a cool spot keeps the fruit fresh and stops the tannin feeling harsh.
A quick way to decide: if the dish is herby, green, or tomato-led, reach for Cabernet Franc. If it is richer, rounder, or built on soft fruit and cream, pour the Merlot.
Cabernet Franc and Merlot in Bordeaux — Why They're Blended
The most famous wines built on these two grapes come from Bordeaux's Right Bank, and understanding the region explains why they are partners rather than rivals.
In Saint-Émilion and Pomerol, Merlot is the dominant grape — often 60 to 90 per cent of the blend — because the clay and limestone soils suit its earlier ripening and give it richness and flesh. Cabernet Franc (known locally in Saint-Émilion as Bouchet) is the classic blending partner, typically making up 10 to 40 per cent, and its job is to add perfume, freshness, structure, and a savoury lift that Merlot alone can lack. Cabernet Sauvignon plays only a minor role here, unlike on the Left Bank where it leads.
The most celebrated example is Château Cheval Blanc in Saint-Émilion, which is unusual for using a very high proportion of Cabernet Franc — often around half the blend — giving it a singular aromatic complexity that has made it one of the most admired wines in the world. Château Ausone also leans heavily on Cabernet Franc. On the other side, Pomerol's legendary Château Pétrus is effectively pure Merlot. Between them, these estates show the full range of what Right Bank blending can achieve.
For a buyer, the practical takeaway is simple. A Right Bank Bordeaux — Saint-Émilion, Pomerol, or one of the satellite appellations — is a Merlot-led wine lifted and structured by Cabernet Franc. If you enjoy that style, the two grapes on their own are a natural next step: a Loire Cabernet Franc to meet the perfume, and a Right Bank or New World Merlot to meet the plush fruit at its fullest.
Recommended Bottles at Every Price Point
Prices and availability shift constantly, so treat these as starting points and check current retail before you buy.
For Cabernet Franc, around £9 to £14 buys a fresh, aromatic Loire bottle from Chinon, Bourgueil, or Saumur-Champigny — the benchmark for the grape's savoury, red-fruited, high-acid style, and superb with food. Around £15 to £25 opens up better single-vineyard Loire wines and warmer-climate New World examples, which show riper, darker fruit with less greenness. Around £25 to £50, a good Saint-Émilion Grand Cru gives you Cabernet Franc woven into a serious Right Bank blend, and top Loire producers such as Clos Rougeard reach well beyond that for collectors.
For Merlot, around £7 to £12 gets you a reliable, soft, fruit-forward bottle from Chile or Washington State — easy everyday drinking. Around £15 to £25 moves you into Columbia Valley Merlot and entry Right Bank Bordeaux, the natural step up in depth and structure. Around £25 to £45 buys a true Saint-Émilion Grand Cru or a Tuscan Merlot, and if you want to splurge, a village-level Pomerol (roughly £50 to £100 at time of writing) is one of the most sensuous reds made anywhere.
A rule holds across both grapes: a modest step up in spend usually buys a disproportionate step up in pleasure — and tasting a Loire Cabernet Franc beside a Right Bank Merlot is one of the most instructive evenings in red wine.
Choose Cabernet Franc when you want a lighter, aromatic, savoury red with bright acidity and real food-friendliness — especially with pork, lamb, herbs, and tomato-based dishes. Choose Merlot when you want something rounder, softer, and plummier that is easy to enjoy on its own or with richer fare. In Bordeaux's greatest Right Bank wines they are blended together — which tells you how well they complement each other.
Common Questions
What is the difference between Cabernet Franc and Merlot?
Cabernet Franc is lighter-bodied, higher in acidity, and more aromatic, with red fruit, violet, and a savoury, herbal edge (bell pepper, tobacco, graphite). Merlot is rounder and softer, with lower acidity, plush plum-and-cherry fruit, and gentler tannins. Cabernet Franc lifts and freshens; Merlot fills and softens. On Bordeaux's Right Bank they are usually blended, with Merlot leading and Cabernet Franc adding perfume and structure.
Which is better, Cabernet Franc or Merlot?
Neither is objectively better — they suit different palates and dishes. Merlot is smoother, fruitier, and easier for beginners; Cabernet Franc is more aromatic, savoury, and food-friendly thanks to its freshness. Some of the world's finest wines (Saint-Émilion, Pomerol) blend the two, which is the strongest sign of how well they complement each other.
Is Cabernet Franc lighter than Merlot?
Usually yes. Cabernet Franc is typically light to medium-bodied with brighter acidity and a firmer, more sinewy tannin, which makes it feel fresher and more lifted. Merlot is medium to full-bodied with softer tannin and lower acidity, so it feels rounder and plusher. Warm-climate examples of either grape gain weight, narrowing the gap.
Why do Cabernet Franc and Merlot taste herbal or green sometimes?
Both grapes contain pyrazine compounds that give herbal, leafy, or green-pepper aromas, and Cabernet Franc has more of them — which is why its savoury, bell-pepper note is a signature rather than a flaw. This character is stronger in cooler climates and cooler vintages, and less noticeable in warm regions like Tuscany, Washington State, or Chile where riper fruit dominates.
Are Cabernet Franc and Merlot related?
Yes. Cabernet Franc is one of the parent grapes of both Merlot and Cabernet Sauvignon, which is why all three blend so naturally in Bordeaux. That shared family lineage is part of the reason Merlot and Cabernet Franc fit together so seamlessly on the Right Bank, where Merlot supplies plush fruit and Cabernet Franc adds perfume, freshness, and structure.
Which ages better, Cabernet Franc or Merlot?
Both age well in their best forms. Top Cabernet Franc from the Loire (Chinon, Bourgueil) and the Right Bank can develop for 10–20 years, gaining tobacco, leather, and dried-flower complexity thanks to its acidity and tannin. Quality Merlot from Pomerol and Saint-Émilion ages beautifully for 10–20 years too, while everyday examples of either grape (under £15) are best drunk within 3–5 years.
Can you substitute Cabernet Franc for Merlot?
In cooking and casual drinking, yes — both are medium-bodied reds that work in red wine reductions, braises, and with roast meats. At the table they lean different ways: Cabernet Franc's freshness and herbal edge suit tomato, herb, and vegetable dishes, while Merlot's soft fruit suits richer, rounder fare. As with any pairing, the quality of the bottle matters more than which of the two grapes it is.
Discover which wines suit your palate with your AI sommelier.
Download on the App Store